Somedays, I think it would be wonderful to get paid to read. Then I realize that no one in their right mind would pay me to read books that have already been published. Oh, well, I guess I am forced to read them in my off time.
Now for my assessment of the following series: The Hunger Games and Divergent. If you have not read either of them and/or are just planning on watching them as they come out in the movies, I'd stop reading now because I am going to spoil the shit out of them.
I am on the second book of the Divergent series. I was hesitant to read it because I am such a huge Hunger Games fan and was worried that maybe it would turn me off to that franchise. It didn't turn me off, per se, but I have spent some time comparing the two internally.
While I will always have a special place in my heart for The Hunger Games (as it was the first dystopian series that I ever picked up) I think that Divergent has weaseled it's way into first place. While they are both written for the Young Adult audience (which, let's face it, I'm not a young adult anymore) The Hunger Games and Divergent are well executed. The difference is that The Hunger Games I would be comfortable with sharing with my gifted six year old now and Divergent would need to wait a few years. Divergent is more likely to hit you where it hurts while the Hunger Games, in a way, sugar coats the effects of war. Yes, it destroyed District 12. Yes, Gale was flogged in the middle of the town square. But not until the very last book (and stop reading NOW to avoid previously mentioned spoilers) does it do any major damage by killing Katniss's sister, Prim. Don't get me wrong, the Hunger Games themselves are brutal but even they scoot around Katniss ever having to do any major killing herself.
Divergent, on the other hand, is brutal from the get go. The Dauntless initiation alone is full of inter-faction maiming, as Edward is stabbed in the eye with a butter knife by Peter and Tris is attacked by the same guy plus her supposed friend, Al. Not only were they intending on killing her (as I'm sure Peter has no conscience and would do just that) they groped her in the process. The fear simulations are terrifying and this is before the war between the factions even starts. Even though they give Tris the ability to overcome the affects of the fear simulation (meaning she can manipulate it to get out of whatever situation arises) the affect is still clear when she has to kill her family. (Although again, she bypasses that by shooting herself.) When the simulation to control the Dauntless begins (which has no power over the Divergent, Tris and Four/Tobias) the emotional toll on the reader quadruples. Tris is powerless to stop the simulation, forced to kill her friend, and eventually watch her mother and father's murders. The only time it gets a little "sugar-coated" (and let's face it, everyone would have been pissed if this hadn't happened) is when she encounters Four under the affects of an injection which held a stronger, Divergent friendly, simulation. She refuses to kill him, he wakes up and they both run off to Amity.
I'm reading the second book now, Insurgent, and it's even more brutal than the first.
Again, sometimes I wish I could give my assessment of these books as a profession. Not that anyone would care, nor listen, but I think I would just love to read all day long. But for now, my children are calling me and I guess I have to go be human for a while.
No comments:
Post a Comment